De Beers Takeover Faces Costly Reality Check

Industry experts warn Botswana that acquiring a bigger stake is only the beginning, with substantial capital needed to revive diamond demand

BONGANI MALUNGA

Botswana’s ambitious plan to double its stake in De Beers from 15 to 30 percent has been met with a sobering reminder from international diamond industry experts that securing ownership of the mining giant could prove easier than financing its long-term recovery.

While President Duma Boko has hailed the proposed acquisition as a historic opportunity for Botswana to gain greater influence over the global diamond industry, experts have cautioned that the transaction itself will not guarantee a return to profitability.

Their warnings shift attention from the ownership structure to a potentially more expensive undertaking, securing sustained capital injections to finance De Beers’ daily operations, rebuild consumer demand and restore the declining appeal of natural diamonds.

DIFFICULT FINANCIAL UNDERTAKING 

Tobias Kormind, co-founder of international diamond jewellery retailer 77 Diamonds, has warned that the Global Diamond Consortium (GDC), which Botswana has endorsed as the preferred bidder for Anglo American’s 85 percent stake, faces a difficult financial and commercial undertaking.

“Beyond the transaction terms, securing substantial ongoing capital investment will be essential for day-to-day operations and rebuilding consumer demand,” Kormind stated in remarks reported by international jewellery publication JCK.

His assessment raises questions about the financial commitments Botswana and its prospective investment partners could face beyond the initial acquisition, particularly as the country grapples with mounting fiscal pressures and a prolonged downturn in diamond revenues.

NO AUTOMATIC REVERSAL 

The warning has been reinforced by Rapaport Chief Executive Officer Dan Mano, who believes that changing De Beers’ ownership will not automatically reverse the industry’s fortunes.

“De Beers remains uniquely positioned to influence the future of the global natural diamond market. But changing ownership alone will not restore confidence. The new owners must demonstrate financial discipline, align rough diamond supply with genuine market demand, and make substantial, sustained investments in global consumer marketing,” Mano stated.

He stressed that the immediate priority must be restoring the desirability, value and profitability of natural diamonds throughout the supply chain.

CHANGING LUXURY MARKET 

Kormind further warned that prospective owners must confront a changing luxury market in which diamonds are increasingly competing with other high-end consumer products. “De Beers once taught the world to desire diamonds. Its prospective owners now face the immense task of rekindling that desire at a time when luxury fashion houses and watchmakers have completely stolen the consumer spotlight,” he observed.

The financial implications could extend beyond marketing expenditure. According to a November 10 Rapaport report, the consortium’s proposed acquisition reportedly involves an upfront payment of US$750 million and a further US$250 million in deferred payments. A separate US$500 million capital injection into De Beers was also reportedly under discussion.

These figures have not been confirmed as binding transaction terms, while Botswana’s precise financial obligations remain undisclosed.

SUBSTANTIAL CAPITAL REQUIREMENTS 

The link between acquisition costs and subsequent capital requirements is particularly significant for Botswana, whose government has yet to publicly detail how the proposed additional 15 percent shareholding will be financed.

During Monday’s State of the Nation Address, Boko announced that Botswana had selected the Gareth Penny-led consortium as its preferred partner, arguing that greater ownership would give the country stronger influence over De Beers’ strategic direction.

IMMEDIATE COMMERCIAL CHALLENGE 

The industry experts’ assessments suggest that the immediate commercial challenge remains restoring the core natural diamond business.

The warnings coincide with renewed production challenges at De Beers’ Botswana operations, where rough diamond output declined by 20 percent to 4.83 million carats during the third quarter of 2026, compared with 6.03 million carats during the corresponding period last year.

According to De Beers’ production report released on 20 October, Orapa experienced a particularly sharp contraction, with output falling by 36 percent to 1.85 million carats, largely due to scheduled plant maintenance.

Jwaneng also recorded a five percent year-on-year decline to 2.98 million carats, while De Beers warned that planned maintenance at the mine during the fourth quarter would substantially reduce Botswana’s production from third-quarter levels.

The latest quarterly setback comes despite Botswana’s cumulative production for the first nine months of 2026 remaining 14 percent above the corresponding period last year, highlighting the uneven recovery across the country’s mining operations.

CHALLENGES 

The operational challenges are compounded by weaker rough diamond prices, with De Beers reporting a 37 percent decline in its consolidated average realised price to US$97 per carat during the first nine months of 2026.

Financial pressure has also persisted despite efforts to contain costs. De Beers recorded an underlying earnings before interest, taxes, depreciation and amortisation (EBITDA) loss of US$113 million during the first half of 2026, although this represented an improvement from the US$189 million loss recorded during the corresponding period in 2025.

In Botswana, underlying EBITDA from mining operations declined from US$227 million to US$119 million despite increased production volumes, illustrating how weaker prices can undermine profitability even when more diamonds are recovered.

The figures reinforce concerns that Botswana’s proposed increase in ownership could coincide with continued pressure on De Beers’ earnings, potentially delaying meaningful investment returns. However, the production reductions also reflect planned maintenance and efforts to balance supply with demand, rather than solely operational deterioration.